Call for Peace
In the Name of Allah,
the Most Gracious, and the Most Merciful
بسم اللہ الرحمٰن الرحیم
Supreme Court Nominations
Analysis of Profile
Mark Judge
Brothers and Sisters!
Assalam o Alleyykum!
The question may emerge in the readers mind that why there was a need to make analysis of Mark Judge’s profile in connection with confirmation of nomination of Judge Brett Kavanaugh?
Brothers and Sisters! The analysis of Mark Judge’s profile deemed necessary for the following reasons:
No 1: Witness of Sexual Assault by Judge Kavanaugh
Brothers and Sisters! Dr Christine Blasey Ford mentioned Mark Judge’s name during her Sexual Assault by Judge Kavanaugh:
Extract: Dr Ford’s Testimony Page No. 3 – 4
One evening that summer, after a day of diving at the club, I attended a small gathering at a house in the Bethesda area. There were four boys I remember specifically being there: Brett Kavanaugh, Mark Judge, a boy named P.J., and one other boy whose name I cannot recall. I also remember my friend Leland attending.
Early in the evening, I went up a very narrow set of stairs leading from the living room to a second floor to use the restroom. When I got to the top of the stairs, I was pushed from behind into a bedroom across from the bathroom. I couldn’t see who pushed me. Brett and Mark came into the bedroom and locked the door behind them.
Both Brett and Mark were drunkenly laughing during the attack. They seemed to be having a very good time.
Mark seemed ambivalent, at times urging Brett on and at times telling him to stop. A couple of times, I made eye contact with Mark and thought he might try to help me, but he did not.
During this assault, Mark came over and jumped on the bed twice while Brett was on top of me. And the last time that he did this, we toppled over and Brett was no longer on top of me. I was able to get up and run out of the room.
No 2: Mark Judge and Judge Kavanaugh were friends since they were in the school:
Brothers and Sisters! Judge Brett Kavanaugh had friendship with Mark Judge since they attended George Preparatory School as per profile of Judge Kavanaugh on Google Network:
Extract: Profile Judge Kavanaugh Page No. 2
Kavanaugh was raised in Bethesda, Maryland. As a teenager he attended Georgetown Preparatory School, a Catholic all-boys high school, where he was two years senior to future U.S. Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch. He was captain of the school’s basketball team, and was a wide receiver and cornerback for the school’s football team Kavanaugh was also friends with classmate Mark Judge; both were in the same class with Maryland State Senate member Richard Madaleno He graduated in 1983.
No 3: Mark Judge and Friends started Drinking at Early age
Brothers and Sisters! Mark Judge started drinking at the age of 14.
Extract: Profile Mark Judge Page No. 1 -2
Judge started drinking at 14. He attended Georgetown Preparatory School, graduating in 1983. Judge was friends with classmate Brett Kavanaugh; both were in the same class there with Maryland State Senate member Richard Madaleno.
Extract: Analysis Book: Tales of Wasted …….
No 1: Page No. 1 – 2
Wasted: Tales of a GenX Drunk is a 1997 memoir about alcoholism, binge drinking, and hook-up culture at Georgetown Preparatory School, written by Mark Gauvreau Judge. Judge recounts his early formative experiences growing up in suburbs of Washington, D.C. under Catholic school education. The author describes his secondary education at Georgetown Preparatory School as filled with heavy drinking and experiences of teenage alcoholism.
No 2: Page No. 2
He recounts attending Catholic educational institutions where drinking alcohol was socially acceptable at a young age. Judge’s behaviour led to clashes with both the priests and the nuns at his Catholic schools. Judge engages in theft of school supplies from nuns.
No 3: Page No 2
Judge recounts for the reader how he felt after imbibing in his first ever alcoholic beverage at the age of 14.
No 4: Page No 3
By the time Judge had turned 15, he and a friend engaged in an Endeavour to provide falsified identification for the purchase of alcohol to all of his fellow students at a secondary education Catholic institution. Judge writes that at age 15 a friend of his who worked as a bartender regularly supplied him with alcoholic beverages for consumption.
No 4: Mark Judge and Friends had sex at early age
Brothers and Sisters! Mark Judge and friends used to have sex while they were at Georgetown Preparatory School:
Extract: Profile Mark Judge Page No.3
Multiple U.S. senators acquired copies of Judge’s books about his time with Kavanaugh at Georgetown Preparatory School, to prepare for questioning Kavanaugh and Ford before the United States Senate Committee on the Judiciary.
In a subsequent New Yorker article, Elizabeth Rasor, who was once in a relationship with Judge for three years, stated that “Mark told me a very different story.”
She said he told her of taking turns having sex with drunk women at Georgetown Prep.
Another woman also disputed Judge’s account of the social scene at the time, sending a letter to Ford’s lawyers saying that she had witnessed boys at parties that included Georgetown Prep students, engaging in sexual misconduct.
Extract: Analysis Book: Tales of Wasted …….
No 1: Page No. 3
The author writes that the social environment of his peers at the school was, “positively swimming in alcohol”.
Judge recounts a hook-up culture involving binge drinking, especially during a period of time at the school known as “Beach Week”. Judge defined “Beach Week” at Georgetown Preparatory School as a “week-long bacchanalia of drinking and sex, or at least attempts at sex“.
No 2: Page No. 3
He presents in-depth memories of orgies and attempts to have sex fuelled with alcohol at residences along the beach shoreline.
No 5: Mark Not Questioned by FBI
Brothers and Sisters! Mark Judge was not questioned by FBI and Senate Judiciary committee during the confirmation hearing.
Extract: Profile Mark Judge Page No. 3
Blumenthal noted, “The third person in the room was Mark Judge, who was never questioned by the FBI or interviewed by the committee.”
No 6: Mark Judge mentions Judge Kavanaugh’s name in his BooK: Wasted Tales….
Brothers and Sisters! Mark Judge mentions Judge Kavanaugh’s name in his book: Wasted: Tales of a GenX Drunk:
Extract: Analysis of Book: Tales of…..
No 1: Page No. 2
Demand for Judge’s work significantly increased after reporting by The Washington Post on his books and the statements by Ford. Washington Monthly and Arkansas Times concluded that “Bart O’Kavanaugh” in Wasted was likely a reference to Brett Kavanaugh.
No 2: Page No. 3
The author discusses a phrase, “100 Kegs Or Bust”, in relation to excessive alcohol drinking during his times at Georgetown Preparatory School. Judge remembers a student he refers to as Bart O’Kavanaugh who passed out and threw up in a car.
No 3: Page No. 4
Brett Kavanaugh. Arkansas Times wrote it was “obviously a nom de plume” for Brett Kavanaugh.
Mother Jones wrote “Kavanaugh appears to make an appearance in the book under the name ‘Bart O’Kavanaugh’.”
The Associated Press wrote that in Judge’s book Wasted, “he makes passing reference to someone with a strikingly similar name “Washington concluded, Judge had “inadequately anonymized Brett Kavanaugh as ‘Bart O’Kavanaugh'”.
No 6: Blackouts
Brothers and Sisters! Mark Judge mentions in his book that due to heavy drinking he used to ‘Blackout’:
Extract: Analysis of Book: Tales of….. Page No. 3
Judge recounts episodes of heavy drinking and blackouts during his four years of study at Catholic University of America. The author is able to graduate from university in spite of heavy alcohol use. Judge acknowledges in the book that in his later twenties, he regularly blacked out while drunk, and awoke in locations with no memory of having arrived there.
No 7: Blackout of Judge Kavanaugh
Brothers and Sisters! Mark Judge mentions in his book about that one of his friends ‘Bart O’Kavanaugh blacked out:
Extract: Analysis of Book: Wasted Tales…. Page No. 2
Judge remembers a student he refers to as Bart O’Kavanaugh who passed out and threw up in a car.
Brothers and Sisters! As below are the questions and answers between Senator Leahy and Judge Kavanaugh:
Extract: Questions and Answers Judge Kavanaugh Page 47 – 48
LEAHY: Judge Kavanaugh, I’ve heard your — your line (ph) and you state it over and over again. And I have that well in mind. But let me ask you this. He authored a book titled, “Wasted: Tales of a Genx Drunk.”
He references a Barthold (ph) Kavanaugh vomiting on someone’s car during Beach Week and then passing out. Is that you that he’s talking about?
KAVANAUGH: Senator, Mark Judge was…
LEAHY: To your knowledge, is that you that he’s talking about?
KAVANAUGH: I’ll explain it if you let me.
LEAHY: Proceed, please.
KAVANAUGH: Mark Judge was a friend of ours in high school who developed a very serious drinking problem, an addiction problem that lasted decades and was very difficult for him to escape from.
And he nearly died. And then developed — then he had leukaemia as well, on top of it.
Now, as part of his therapy — or part of his coming to grips with sobriety, he wrote a book that is a fictionalized book and an account….
(CROSSTALK)
KAVANAUGH: I think he picked out names of friends of ours to throw them in as kind of close to what — for characters in the book. So, you know, we can sit here…
LEAHY: So you don’t know — you don’t know whether that’s you or not?
KAVANAUGH: … we can sit here and you (ph) like (ph), make — make fun of some guy who has an addiction.
LEAHY: I’m not making…
(CROSSTALK)
KAVANAUGH: I don’t think that really makes — is really good…
LEAHY: … Judge Kavanaugh, I’m trying to get a straight answer from you under oath. Are you Bart (ph) Kavanaugh that he’s referring to, yes or no? That’s it (ph)…
KAVANAUGH: You’d have to ask him.
Observation
Brothers and Sisters! From the above questions and answers it can safely be deduced that Judge Brett Kavanaugh was trying to evade to answer the question where the simple answer should have been ‘Yes’ or ‘No’. And finally he did not answer the question and replied:
You’d have to ask him.
OBSERVATIONS
Brothers and Sisters! The analysis as above depict that Judge Brett Kavanaugh and Mark Judge were close friends where friendship started at the age of 14 when they were in High school and they are still friends after 36 years. So it can be safely assumed that they drank together, they went to parties together and they also targeted young girls for sex together. Therefore, the allegation by Dr Christine Blasey Ford and ‘True’ where it can be safely assumed that Judge Brett Kavanaugh was not Truthful in his testimony on Oath and similarly Mark Judge’s sworn statement on oath is not true.
Wass’a’lam
[May Allah Bless You]
Naseer Aziz
Principal Call for Peace